In a City Journal article, author Steven Malanga argues that Colorado, Washington, and Oregon—once booming magnets for domestic migrants—are now exhibiting early signs of decline mirroring California's long-running dysfunction, driven by a shift to one-party Democratic rule and the adoption of progressive policies on energy, housing, taxes, and regulation. Key indicators include reversing migration trends (e.g., Colorado's net domestic gains plummeting from 390,000 in 2010-2020 to just 24,000 since 2020), lagging job growth below national averages, skyrocketing housing costs (e.g., Portland and Seattle's price-to-income ratios exceeding 6:1), and urban decay from crime and homelessness, as seen in Portland's post-2020 riots slashing police forces and Denver's high vacancy rates amid lax enforcement. While not yet as severe as California's "mirage," these states face budget shortfalls (e.g., Washington's $6-12 billion gap) and business flight, contrasting with thriving red states like Texas and Florida; Malanga warns that without policy reversals, the "California dream" will become a full nightmare.
Colorado, Washington, and Oregon’s slide into progressive quicksand proves once again that aping California’s nanny-state playbook—endless regulations, green-energy mandates that jack up costs, and a blind eye to skyrocketing crime and homelessness—is a recipe for exodus and economic stagnation. These states, fresh off a decade of luring families with jobs and fresh air, are now hemorrhaging residents and businesses because Democrat overlords like Colorado’s Jared Polis prioritize virtue-signaling over viability: resisting deportations in Denver while crime festers, or slashing Portland’s cops post-riots, turning downtowns into ghost towns with 25% drops in foot traffic and 90% fire-sale office discounts. It’s no coincidence that while Texas and Florida rake in surpluses and migrants, these blue havens bleed billions in shortfalls and watch startups flee burdensome taxes and red tape.
The data doesn’t lie—net migration flips from +390,000 in Colorado’s boom years to a pathetic +24,000 now, with job growth cratering below the national average. Blame the one-party stranglehold that’s turned purple promise into blue despair: Washington’s tax hikes under Inslee, Oregon’s sluggish economy chasing firms away, and all three’s EV mandates and zoning strangleholds inflating housing beyond reach. Families aren’t fleeing for the weather; they’re escaping the mirage of “equity” that leaves everyone poorer. Time for these states to ditch the California cargo cult and rediscover the conservative basics—cut regs, back the badge, and let free enterprise breathe—before they join the Golden State’s hall of fiscal shame.